White supremacy vs. Jewish supremacy: What actually describes the United States?

2 months - 18 posts - Latest - RSS
OP: 7 Goods vs 3 No Goods
Thread: 45 Goods vs 27 No Goods

Sociology Job Market Rumors » Off Topic » Politics

White supremacy vs. Jewish supremacy: What actually describes the United States?

Sociologist
72dd

I've been told that the United States is under a form of "structural racism" called "white supremacy," and have been shown evidence including differences in average income, differences in health outcomes, and higher rates of whites in particular industries.

If we apply the exact methodology of CRT consistently, without a priori determination that "whites" must be the group always designated as most powerful, what would the results be? If we apply CRT methodology toward the hypothesis of Jewish supremacy: isn't Jewish supremacy a far more accurate rendering of the actual structural situation in America in statistical terms? Isn't calling it "white supremacy" deliberately obfuscating that the most privileged sub-group among whites, that actually holds structural supremacy in media and finance, would be Jewish people?

2 months ago # QUOTE 7 GOOD 3 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
9432

https://romulusstudio.com/variant/16texts/Chomsky.html

By now J/e/w/s in the US are the most privileged and influential part of the population. You find occasional instances of anti-Semitism but they are marginal. There's plenty of racism, but it's directed against Blacks, Latinos, Arabs are targets of enormous racism, and those problems are real. Anti-Semitism is no longer a problem, fortunately. It's raised, but it's raised because privileged people want to make sure they have total control, not just 98% control. That's why anti-Semitism is becoming an issue.
-- Noam Chomsky

2 months ago # QUOTE 4 GOOD 2 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
5cc8

I wonder about what a substantive response to this would look like.
Critical race theorists basically follow the same methodology as "Neo-Nazis" who count the number of Jewish people in leading positions of particular industries. Critical race theorists also count these same Jewish people, but then refer to them as "white."

If we made a hard categorical line distinguishing "white" from "Jewish," and only counted people as one or the other, wouldn't the hypothesis of "white supremacy" and "white privilege" fall apart entirely, and wouldn't it emerge that "white people" are actually a marginalized majority in America? (while Jewish people are the market-dominant minority?)

This is a question about methodology. My impression is that the only reason why these specific methods would not be used is because the Jewish Lobby (ADL and ilk) would complain and call it "anti-semitic," not because it would be "wrong social science."

2 months ago # QUOTE 5 GOOD 2 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
4491

This "sociologist" says 97% of hedge fund managers are white men and this generates societal inequality:
https://time.com/6132594/hedged-out-book-hedge-fund-inequality/

However, as of 2016, out of 24 top hedge fund managers, 17 were Jewish. 8 of the 10 top hedge fund managers were Jewish. (I will list names if asked.)

See above:

Critical race theorists basically follow the same methodology as "Neo-Nazis" who count the number of Jewish people in leading positions of particular industries. Critical race theorists also count these same Jewish people, but then refer to them as "white."

If we made a hard categorical line distinguishing "white" from "Jewish," and only counted people as one or the other, wouldn't the hypothesis of "white supremacy" and "white privilege" fall apart entirely, and wouldn't it emerge that "white people" are actually a marginalized majority in America? (while Jewish people are the market-dominant minority?)

70-80% of those actually managing leading hedge funds are Jewish.
Let's estimate that top hedge fund managers are:
71% Jewish
16% non-Jewish white
3% other

In the United States, approximately 30% of the population are white males, approximately 0.8% of the population are Jewish males.
Worldwide, approximately 7% of the global population are white males (varying by who is defined as white) and 0.1% of the global population are Jewish males.

Jewish men not only manage the vast majority of hedge fund wealth, but compared to non-Jewish white men are disproportionately over/represented by nearly 350 times. Doesn't the data that Tobias Neely highlights as evidence of "structural racism," when we actually look at it more closely, suggest the "structural racism" at work in global capitalism is in fact Jewish supremacy?

Does anyone have a re
...See full post

2 months ago # QUOTE 5 GOOD 3 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
4491

That should read:
71% Jewish
26% non-Jewish white
3% other

I edited quickly, initially was using the 80% rate of top hedge funds, then edited to go with the larger group, but overlooked changing this or conflated the two figures.

This also implies the rate of over/representation of Jewish men compared to non-Jewish white men is more than 200 times, but not nearly 350 times as stated in the previous post.

2 months ago # QUOTE 4 GOOD 2 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
4491

https://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/why-are-most-hedge-fund-managers-jewish
^ This thread happens to include the names of 8 of 10 leading hedge fund managers, as Jewish. Anyone can confirm this information elsewhere as well.

Sociologists cannot simultaneously claim 97% of hedge fund managers being white men is evidence of a white supremacist system, but then try to claim the fact that 80% are Jewish men would somehow not a result at all of any racial supremacist system favoring Jewish men.

2 months ago # QUOTE 5 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
a2e5

White non-Jewish men are 29% of the US population, but are only 26% of leading hedge fund managers. They are not only not dominant in finance, but are not even over/represented in the specific field where a "social scientist" is trying to depict them as totally dominant.
Why is Neely focusing on "white men" instead of "Jewish men"? Isn't focusing on the latter going to indicate a more detailed picture of reality?

Surely some Democrat sociologist here must have a substantive response to this line of analysis?

2 months ago # QUOTE 7 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
487b

Sounds very neo-liberal.

2 months ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 3 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
a628

Sounds very neo-liberal.

^ Whenever the stalker lets this f/a/r/t out, you know the DNC Bros have lost the argument in the thread.

2 months ago # QUOTE 4 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
85fe

All of the above might be true, but this gives zero solace to those visibly Jewish (mostly orthodox) people who wonder if they're going to be assaulted as they walk down the sidewalk.

2 months ago # QUOTE 2 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
a628

All of the above might be true, but this gives zero solace to those visibly Jewish (mostly orthodox) people who wonder if they're going to be assaulted as they walk down the sidewalk.

Plenty of non-Jewish white people are also assaulted and even murdered. The difference is that racial assaults targeting whites are almost never classified as hate crimes, even when the assailant avowedly expresses anti-white hatred on social media before the attack.

2 months ago # QUOTE 2 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
c1e8

coursework help
design technology coursework
coursework plagiarism

2 months ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d6ed

You sound jealous.

This "sociologist" says 97% of hedge fund managers are white men and this generates societal inequality:
https://time.com/6132594/hedged-out-book-hedge-fund-inequality/
However, as of 2016, out of 24 top hedge fund managers, 17 were Jewish. 8 of the 10 top hedge fund managers were Jewish. (I will list names if asked.)
See above:
Critical race theorists basically follow the same methodology as "Neo-Nazis" who count the number of Jewish people in leading positions of particular industries. Critical race theorists also count these same Jewish people, but then refer to them as "white."
If we made a hard categorical line distinguishing "white" from "Jewish," and only counted people as one or the other, wouldn't the hypothesis of "white supremacy" and "white privilege" fall apart entirely, and wouldn't it emerge that "white people" are actually a marginalized majority in America? (while Jewish people are the market-dominant minority?)
70-80% of those actually managing leading hedge funds are Jewish.
Let's estimate that top hedge fund managers are:
71% Jewish
16% non-Jewish white
3% other
In the United States, approximately 30% of the population are white males, approximately 0.8% of the population are Jewish males.
Worldwide, approximately 7% of the global population are white males (varying by who is defined as white) and 0.1% of the global population are Jewish males.
Jewish men not only manage the vast majority of hedge fund wealth, but compared to non-Jewish white men are disproportionately over/represented by nearly 350 times. Doesn't the data that Tobias Neely highlights as evidence of "structural racism," when we actually look at it more closely, suggest the "structural racism" at work in global capitalism is in fact Jewish supremacy?
Does anyone ha
...See full post

2 months ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 4 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
a557

You sound jealous.

Jealous of what?

So weird that J/e/w/s are allegedly the most intelligent ethnic category yet still practice a brutal superstitious Bronze Age mutilation ritual against children that has no medical justification. Whose fault is that exactly?

3 weeks ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
25f4

Article on J/e/w/s and slavery:
https://bit.ly/3y6dFMz

3 weeks ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d2d8

Sounds very neo-liberal.

3 weeks ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 3 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
225d

All of the above might be true, but this gives zero solace to those visibly Jewish (mostly orthodox) people who wonder if they're going to be assaulted as they walk down the sidewalk.
Black people do that to Asians as well.

3 weeks ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
7401

Employers searching his name, this post was made by Stephen Michael Clark, the stalker who targets sociologists from his basement in De Pijp.

3 weeks ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !

White supremacy vs. Jewish supremacy: What actually describes the United States?

Reply