LOL political scientist with no publications hired by Columbia removes CV

11 months - 140 posts - Latest - RSS
OP: 11 Goods vs 2 No Goods
Thread: 434 Goods vs 311 No Goods

Sociology Job Market Rumors » Sociology » Sociology Discussion

LOL political scientist with no publications hired by Columbia removes CV

« Previous 123…7 Next »

Sociologist
1ae9

I am the poster to which you were responding. NBER and SSRN are not publications. These are repositories for working papers. At the top of the market you get hired on the basis of the promise of your JMP and/or other working papers. Nothing that you wrote contradicts anything that I wrote.

You don't know much about economics or political science.
Candidates in economics and political science may not have official pubs but must have visible working papers and some oral presentations. In general, job market papers can be published in either the NBER or the SSRN.

11 months ago # QUOTE 4 GOOD 2 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
1ae9

Also, to be clear, job market candidates do not have papers posted to NBER server unless they are co-authored with a faculty member who is an NBER research associate. Candidate JMPs are not on NBER.

You don't know much about economics or political science.
Candidates in economics and political science may not have official pubs but must have visible working papers and some oral presentations. In general, job market papers can be published in either the NBER or the SSRN.
On the econ, polisci job markets, most job candidates don't have publications. They have a job market paper that people think is destined for a top journal. It's only in criminology that people enter the market with a laundry list of publications.

11 months ago # QUOTE 4 GOOD 2 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
91f8

Knight has been quite traumatized by being called out here. It's quite funny. Po' po' little David.

11 months ago # QUOTE 4 GOOD 4 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
8859

Yes, economics is pathological, and hires people with no evidence of productivity. But that is not typical of most disciplines. A publication record is usually expected in sociology. (Source: was hired, have hired others.) Most faculty do care about letters to some extent, though it varies a lot - the candidate's proven record usually matters more, as does (sadly) the prestige of their department.

11 months ago # QUOTE 6 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
a08f

Go to sleep.

Yes, economics is pathological, and hires people with no evidence of productivity. But that is not typical of most disciplines. A publication record is usually expected in sociology. (Source: was hired, have hired others.) Most faculty do care about letters to some extent, though it varies a lot - the candidate's proven record usually matters more, as does (sadly) the prestige of their department.

11 months ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 6 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
dc34

What you're saying is very funny. We're talking about Knight, the guy who removed his resume from his website.

In political science, it is suspicious that no working paper has been posted.

I am a tenured professor but you're quite right that I'm not a sociologist. At the high end of the market, letters are basically everything. And by letters, I don't mean only what is written in the letter itself but the phone call one's advisor makes on behalf of the candidate. That is how things happen. This is not a bean counting exercise.
You are neither a tenured professor nor a sociologist. "JMP" is not a term used in sociology. And no one cares about letters!!!! "telling it like it is." LMFAO
Sounds like I should have gotten my PhD in econ. Tired of the bean counting in soc/crim.
The bean counting in sociology, but especially criminology, is why we have the "stars" that we have. People will have 100+ publications without contributing a single meaningful or original thing to the discipline. They are just experts at getting published.

11 months ago # QUOTE 1 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d857

You seem to be one of those losers who doesn't have anything to contribute.

I am a tenured professor but you're quite right that I'm not a sociologist. At the high end of the market, letters are basically everything. And by letters, I don't mean only what is written in the letter itself but the phone call one's advisor makes on behalf of the candidate. That is how things happen. This is not a bean counting exercise.
You are neither a tenured professor nor a sociologist. "JMP" is not a term used in sociology. And no one cares about letters!!!! "telling it like it is." LMFAO
Sounds like I should have gotten my PhD in econ. Tired of the bean counting in soc/crim.
The bean counting in sociology, but especially criminology, is why we have the "stars" that we have. People will have 100+ publications without contributing a single meaningful or original thing to the discipline. They are just experts at getting published.

11 months ago # QUOTE 1 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d112

Is he now gen0cideizEd due to sjmr abuse and need extra salary and 5 years to earn tenure?

11 months ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d857

SJMR doesn't traumatize anyone. Unpublished experiences do.

Is he now gen0cideizEd due to sjmr abuse and need extra salary and 5 years to earn tenure?

11 months ago # QUOTE 1 GOOD 2 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
80cf

Has anyone heard the latest

11 months ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d857

LOL what the Democrats did

11 months ago # QUOTE 3 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d857

FK off

11 months ago # QUOTE 1 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
e365

He did groundbreaking research like any average femin@zzi in academia. Ok?

11 months ago # QUOTE 1 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
f637

why do non-publishers trash other non-publishers?

11 months ago # QUOTE 4 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d191

Knight has been quite traumatized by being called out here. It's quite funny. Po' po' little David.

Well, he would be wouldn't he. He's one of the fraqiles.

11 months ago # QUOTE 2 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
d857

Can we get that dk out of soc?

11 months ago # QUOTE 1 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
2d5a

Is he now gen0cideizEd due to sjmr abuse and need extra salary and 5 years to earn tenure?

Yes. His faqgulty mentor TM has also created a safe space with stuffed animals for him

11 months ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
3217

Is he now gen0cideizEd due to sjmr abuse and need extra salary and 5 years to earn tenure?
Yes. His faqgulty mentor TM has also created a safe space with stuffed animals for him

Kum ba yah, my lord, kum ba yah.

11 months ago # QUOTE 0 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
e365

Be nice guys; He is bringing CRT into political theory

11 months ago # QUOTE 1 GOOD 1 NO GOOD !
Sociologist
ec8a

Hi, Knight!
At least show me something, like a normal candidate in political science.
Like pronouns in an e-mail signature to advertise how you’re a fre~ak?

11 months ago # QUOTE 2 GOOD 0 NO GOOD !

« Previous 123…7 Next »

LOL political scientist with no publications hired by Columbia removes CV

Reply »